Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Housemade French Onion Soup
Lumberjack Pancake Breakfast
Arkville Vly Creek Bloody Mary
Spicy Chipotle Bloody Mary
About
Sportsman's Alamo Cantina
Welcome to Sportsman's Alamo Cantina, a culinary gem nestled in the charming town of Phoenicia, New York. Located at 70 Main St, this delightful eatery is renowned for its warm atmosphere and mouthwatering menu offerings. Just a stone’s throw from the breathtaking hiking trails of the Catskills, it’s the perfect spot to refuel after an adventurous day in nature.
Sportsman’s Alamo Cantina boasts an impressive array of dishes designed to satisfy every appetite. The Triple Decker Turkey Club is a crowd favorite, stacked high with fresh ingredients, while the Grilled Reuben provides a delightful twist on a classic. For lovers of Italian flavors, the Hot Italian Grinder and Tuscan Chicken Sandwich are must-tries, bursting with savory goodness. And don’t miss out on the hearty Philly Cheese Steak, a true comfort food triumph.
But it doesn’t stop at sandwiches—Sportsman's also excels with its calzones. The Ricotta, Mozzarella, and Parmesan Cheese Calzone is a rich, satisfying option, while the house-made sausage variation offers a unique, flavorful experience that will keep you coming back for more.
For breakfast lovers, the selection of omelettes will surely entice you. Whether you opt for the simple yet classic Traditional Cheese Omelette, or the hearty Farmers' Omelette packed with seasonal veggies, you’re in for a treat. Each dish is crafted with care, ensuring a delightful start to your day.
Customers rave about their experiences at Sportsman's Alamo Cantina. Rebecca W. notes, "Well worth our 45-minute drive every time we come! Staff is absolutely amazing and the food is as well." Rissa highlights the thin crust pizza and pecan salad as "absolutely outrageous," emphasizing the excellent service that complements every meal.
Despite the occasional slip, many reviews celebrate the restaurant's dedication to outstanding food. Paul Tonkay shares that while service wasn't perfect during his visit, the food—particularly the burger—was among the best he’s had. This speaks volumes about the kitchen's ability to consistently deliver exceptional flavors.
If you’re in search of a vibrant spot to unwind, relax, and indulge, look no further than Sportsman's Alamo Cantina. With its friendly staff, generous portions, and a menu that caters to every craving, it’s a slice of culinary paradise in upstate New York. Whether you're dining indoors or enjoying their outdoor seating, you're guaranteed a memorable experience.
Visit them today or call +1 845-688-5259 for more information. Trust us; you won't be disappointed!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Well worth our 45 minute drive everytime we come! Staff is absolutely amazing and the food is as well. Perfect spot for any meal any time! ”
“ We has a large thin crust pizza , and a pecan salad ! Absolutely outrageous, the pizza was better then we have ever had ! Peacan salad was fantastic, oh and not to mention the service is impeccable. ”
“ Let me start off by saying the food is amazing! My wife and myself hiked Mt Tremper today and looking forward to a good meal and a cold drink. We walked in and were told pick from the menu and have a seat the server will bring the food. No problems we understand due to Covid, that being said the server was either having a bad day or hates her job. She brought our food (which was amazing the burger is best around by far) and never returned or asked how our meal was. I am usually not one to leave a negative review but her attitude and service was bad. Now that being said I must compliment the rest of the restaraunt staff the beer choice is terrific and both my wife and my meals were outstanding for that you deserve 5 stars and thank you. ”
“ Just a great place to eat, have fun, and enjoy the day with the out door dining. Staff super friendly. Get ready to eat because the portions are huge. My burrito looked like a blanket stuffed with meat... so yummy.... wide ranging items to choose from... great bar inside with out door ordering access ”
“ My husband and I were in town just for the weekend, and were looking for dinner on a Sunday night. The location had some changes due to COVID-19 precautions (ordering drinks and food in one area, seating in another). It was a lovely dining experience, with hearty food, excellent desserts, and amazing staff. Dawn, our waitress, was an absolute delight and incredibly attentive. Highly recommended! ”
“ Wonderful place while visiting Phoenicia. The portions are huge and you have enough leftovers for the next day or two. The food itself is delicious. The tacos are the juiciest I’ve ever had. Feels slow cooked with lots of love. The beans are rice are delicious as well. The wings and salmon are ok, a bit over cooked but nonetheless ok. Would recommend :) ”
“ The food was delicious and the selection enormous. They had three different menus with a whole assortment of food. One of the things that really stood out to me was how prompt the service was. Our waiter checked in on us frequently and when we needed something he was there. Everyone was pleasant and polite. All three of us enjoyed our meals and we will definitely go back again. Also, that had what may be the best refried beans I've ever eaten. ”
“ Great food, humongous portions, friendly and super efficient service. Nice ambiance overall. What else one needs? Great selection of local beers :) Definitely will come again. ”